SFJ

Facebook  YouTube

Small Farmer's Journal
PO Box 1627
Sisters, Oregon 97759
800-876-2893
541-549-2064
agrarian@smallfarmersjournal.com
Mon - Thu, 8am - 4pm PDT

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction
SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Arch skidder and wheeled pole arch in test section C.

HELLMANS Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Test report SmP 2015-2

by Paul Schmit of Tuntange, Luxembourg and Albano Moscardo of Verona, Italy www.schaffmatpaerd.org schaffmatpaerd@pt.lu

Abstract

By a comparison test in Swedish forest, different horse drawn logging equipment, manufactured by HELLMANS from HERRLJUNGA (SWEDEN), was analyzed.

The trials, which took place in August 2015, showed that lifting the log from the ground, either at the front and/or at the rear, by adapted equipment during the logging, has great benefits concerning the required tractive effort of the horse.

Furthermore, it was found that wheeled equipment can be extremely advantageous, this not just for increasing the efficiency of the logging operation, but also for the horse’s comfort at work.

All tested equipment proved to be of sufficient strength to support the high loads in forestry use, while being at the same time lightweight enough for easy maneuverings in the forest.

In order to eliminate uneven loads and peak stresses, articulated hitch devices, following the alternate movement of the horse’s shoulders, should be given preference over rigid shaft assemblies.

Further information about a horse’s acceptable draft power can be found at www.schaffmatpaerd.org.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

General view of measuring equipment.

Introduction

Over centuries, in many European regions, horse-logging operations followed old traditions, and are still doing this today. In Central Europe, skidding logs on the ground by a simple singletree is a common practice.

Traditionally, Swedish horse loggers used wooden sleighs. This changed in the fifties, when extracting timber was not just limited to the winter months, with the large forest areas covered for months with snow. Today, Sweden is a pioneer in horse logging equipment and there exists a wide range of horse drawn tools offered by five companies, that manufacture it beside other professional activities. Most equipment is nowadays made in steel and often hotgalvanized, assuring a long operational life under rough forest use.

Another distinctive feature of the draft horse use in Scandinavian countries is the hitch system. In general, the traces are not drawn out to a singletree, but consist only of small tug straps, which connect the hames to a central tug ring between the pack pad and the belly band. In this ring is inserted a draft bar made of flat iron with a slot and a safety pin, which allows one to fix shafts on both sides of the harness. Herein, the shafts have a triple function. Besides the transmission of the tractive and steering forces, they also allow to brake the load, a not to be underestimated safety aspect.

Traditionally, these shafts have been rigid and made of timber. The simplest and most economic solution for people working in the forest. However, research done in 2016 and 2017 by SmP at the SWEDISH ARMY MUSEUM in STOCKHOLM (SWEDEN) and in the NORDIC MUSEUM at JULITA GÅRD (SWEDEN) led to the conclusion that articulated shafts have been in use beginning at the end of the 19th century. Mainly for team hitches in forest or farm use, non-rigid shaft assemblies were offered alongside rigid shafts by major Swedish wagon manufacturers as standard equipment around 1920. Today however, rigid shafts still can be found on modern forest equipment, especially on arch skidders.

When the horse walks, its shoulders perform alternate backward and forward movements. The Scandinavian style shafts, being directly connected to the collar via the front tug straps and with the collar resting on the shoulders, can follow these movements, when being articulated along a vertical axis, allowing a longitudinal movement of both shaft sides.

Therefore, within the trials for the present report, the influence of rigid vs. articulated shafts on the shoulder strain has also been examined. This by a comparison of the left and right side forces in the harness.

One of the goals of the non-profit association Schaff mat Päerd is, beside its own prototype development and manufacturing, to support other equipment manufacturers through the testing of their products and publishing related studies.

The present test report covers the standard logging equipment offered by HELLMANS from HERRLJUNGA (SWEDEN). Besides training courses for working with draft horses, HELLMANS offers services with horses in various domains and manufactures standard as well as customized solutions for horse drawn equipment. Further information about their product range can be found at www.backagard.net.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Technical characteristics of the equipment:

Total width:
Singletree – 800 mm
Log grapple – 305 mm (max. opening 65 mm)
Skid shafts – 1000 mm
Arch skidder – 950 mm
Wheeled pole arch – 1250 mm
4-wheel forwarder – 1330 mm

Total length:
Singletree – 50 mm
Log grapple – 1300 mm (including chain)
Skid shafts – 2200 mm
Arch skidder – 2700 mm
Wheeled pole arch – 1450 mm
4-wheel forwarder – 5800 mm (including shafts)

Total height:
Singletree – 30 mm
Log grapple – 305 mm
Skid shafts – 360 mm
Arch skidder – 850 mm
Wheeled pole arch – 900 mm
4-wheel forwarder – 1400 mm

Tare weight:
Singletree – 2,9 kg
Log grapple – 10,4 kg
Skid shafts – 20,5 kg
Arch skidder – 30,0 kg
Wheeled pole arch – 62,0 kg
4-wheel forwarder – 230 kg

Log in the test:
Diameter: front 360 mm / rear 280 mm
Length: 3300 mm
Weight: 221 kg

Horse in the test:
Name: Mojje
Breed: Swedish Ardennes
Date of birth: 01.06.1998
Height: 1,62 m
Weight: 900 kg
Collar size: 25” half sweeny

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Skid shafts in test section E.

Materials and methods

The measuring tests took place in a forest adjacent to the BÄCKAGÅRD farm of the HELLMAN family in HERRLJUNGA (SWEDEN) on 14.08.15.

In order to evaluate the required tractive effort of each piece of equipment, the draft forces were measured on five different test sections A to E with the following ground conditions and lengths:

A forest track flat 15 m
B forest track uphill 49 m with 9,25 % pitch
C forest flat 53 m
D forest uphill 25 m with 13 % pitch followed by forest flat 12 m
E forest downhill 17 m with 15 % pitch

All measurements were made between 10.30 – 12.30 and 13.30 – 15.00 o’clock. This relatively long test duration was due to the breaks, in which the next piece of equipment to be tested was prepared in the forest and the horse was driven to its stable at the farm for resting. This allowed that all tests were done under nearly the same conditions.

The measuring device consisted of the following components:

– two Lorenz K-100 force sensors mounted between the leather front tug straps and the central tug rings on both sides of the harness

– an AHLBORN Almemo 2690-8 data logger with memory connector and micro SD card saddled on the back pad of the harness

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Arch skidder in test section C.

The mounting of the draft force sensors in the front tug straps and the saddled data logger allowed for the change of the whole measuring device from one equipment to the next without any adaptation.

In order to assure the best working comfort of the test horse, the collar, collar pad, back pad and breeching were the horse’s own harness parts. SmP supplied the adjustable wooden “Lone Star” hames, the front tug straps with measuring device as well as the leather traces, the latter in use for the trials with the singletree.

The total draft force, represented in the following graphs, is a calculation. Preliminary tests of the measuring equipment on the SCHMIT-LAROCHE farm in TUNTANGE (LUXEMBOURG), performed on 06.04.15, and the corresponding data analyzing showed that the adding up of both single values of the left/right side draft forces is of adequate accuracy for the present considerations.

The measured values were recorded with a summary-measuring rate of 100 Hz resulting in a frequency of 33 Hz for each of the three dimensions (time, left side draft force and right side draft force).

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

4-wheel forwarder in test section C.

Results

According to the expectations, a comparison of the test sections A and C in the graphs 1 to 7 shows that the overgrown forest ground requires more draft force than the forest track, on average + 25 %.

The summary graph 9 not just points out the influence of the different equipment, but also of the ground conditions and slopes. As expected, the highest tractive effort for all tested equipment is required on the steep uphill part of test section D. However, the downhill test section E, at the end of the test circuit back to the starting point, doesn’t stand out from the measured values. It is, for most of the tested equipment, on the same level as the flat forest path of the test section A. This underlines again the influence of the ground conditions. The same is true for the test sections B and C, requiring nearly the same expenditure of force for all tested equipment.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Another trait to be highlighted can be found by comparison of the graphs 1 and 2. Considering just the summary graph 9 would lead to the conclusion that the singletree with log grapple, known as “Domänsax” in Sweden, requires the same tractive effort as the skid shafts. However, the two above mentioned graphs show clearly the shock-absorbing effect of the full-length leather traces connected to the singletree. Graph 2, related to the steel skid shafts, shows significantly higher draft force peaks, exceeding even 6 kN, which corresponds to a total impact load on the harness and by that also to both shoulders of 621 kg. Even in millisecond range, this strain is not to be neglected, especially as it can be assumed that the short nylon-reinforced front tug straps have a limited absorbing capacity.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

By comparison of graph 2 to all other graphs, it can be concluded that the steel skid shafts, dragging the log on the ground and transmitting the impact forces almost undamped, is the most inefficient and uncomfortable way of working for the horse.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Even having steel shafts, the arch skidder, represented in graphs 3 and 4 shows significantly better characteristics than the single tree with log grapple or the skid shafts. This logging tool not only requires a smaller draft effort by the horse, but also offers smoother motion sequences. This can be explained by the fact that the front end of the log is slightly lifted from the ground creating less shock loads and lower friction forces.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Graphs 4, 5 and 6, relating to the trials made with the wheeled pole arch, lifting the rear end of the log, point out the advantageous influence of this logging tool. In all three combinations, with the log grapple connected to the singletree, with the skid shafts and with the arch skidder, the load of the horse can be reduced considerably. A fact which also clearly emerges from the summary graphs 8 and 9. Within this context, it is not surprising that the combination of the two arch type logging tools at the front and the rear end of the log offers the best results of the skidding tools. This despite the fact, noticed during the trials, that the log tends to swing back and forward in the arch skidder because of the low friction coefficient of the wheels at the rear.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

In spite of its high own tare weight, listed in the technical data above, the 4-wheel forwarder can be rated best. Represented in graph 7 and in comparison to the other logging equipment, this basic wheeled forwarder, known as “Fössing” in Sweden, comes up with the lowest total draft force average values and peaks within this test series. This thanks to the low rolling friction and the suspension characteristics of the pneumatic wheels. Furthermore the log, as being completely contactless with the ground and tightly fixed to the forwarder’s frame, didn’t interfere anymore in the motion sequences of the hitch.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Following the graph 7, the 4-wheel forwarder allows to reduce the draft force peaks to 50% and the average draft force requirements to 11 … 45 % of the singletree / log grapple combination. In simplified terms, the horse has to pull with the wheeled forwarder half as hard as in the ground skidding method.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Summary graph 8 clearly points out that, for nearly all the test sequences, the left side shoulder of the horse was subjected to more physical stress than the right side. Therefore, beside examining the average draft force requirements of the different logging tools, another main test content was the analysis of the left/ right side draft forces on each piece of equipment and especially the influence of articulated vs. rigid shafts on the shoulder pressure.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

As explained above, the arch skidder helps reduce the draft force needed to pull the log, by lifting the log’s front end. However, as can be seen in the summary graph 8, the highest imbalance between the left and right side draft force have been measured on this tool, either alone or in combination with the wheeled pole arch. This can be explained by the rigid frame construction, which cannot follow the alternating forward movement sequences of both shoulders of the horse.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

This correlation is also visible in graphs 3 and 4 where the green curve, related to the left side, is more pronounced and oscillating than the yellow line, related to the right side.

All tested equipment proved to be of sufficient strength to support the high loads in forestry use, while being at the same time lightweight enough for easy maneuverings in the forest. No failures, like bent parts or cracked welds, have been noticed during or after the tests.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Singletree with log grapple in test section D.

Discussion

All tested equipment can be recommended for forest use, however skid shafts or log grapples connected to a singletree mainly for smaller loads due to their unfavorable motion characteristics.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Arch skidder and wheeled pole arch in test section C.

Wheeled forwarders, either in 4-, 6- or 8-wheel configuration, are popular tools among Swedish horse loggers. The present test report highlights the technical superiority of this equipment compared to the tools sliding on the ground.

Related to the issue of animal welfare, the importance of shock absorption should be addressed when working with non-lifted logs and steel shafts.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Skid shafts and wheeled pole arch between test sections B and C.

Furthermore, following the present test values, articulated shafts should be given preference and should become the standard in the future on all equipment, not just for forest, but also for farm use. In particular for a better working comfort of the horse.

In additional tests, the different wheeled forwarders, actually on the market, should be examined in order to compare their characteristics and for confirming the conclusions of this test report.

SmP Hellmans Logging Equipment for Horse Traction

Singletree with log grapple and wheeled pole arch in test section A.

Spotlight On: Equipment & Facilities

Cockshutt Plow Found in Alberta

Cockshutt Plow Found in Alberta!

Dale Befus introduced me to a plow I had not set eyes on before, most unusual affair though Dale assures me not uncommon in Alberta, this implement is a beam-hung riding plow (wheels hang from the beam) as versus the frame-hung units (where the beam hangs under the wheel-supported frame).

Mowing with Scythes

Mowing with Scythes

by:
from issue:

Scythes were used extensively in Europe and North America until the early 20th century, after which they went out of favor as farm mechanization took off. However, the scythe is gaining new interest among small farmers in the West who want to mow grass on an acre or two, and could be a useful tool for farmers in the Tropics who do not have the resources to buy expensive mowing equipment.

"Work Horse Handbook, 2nd Edition" by Lynn Miller

Draft Collars and How To Size Them

It is difficult to accurately measure a horse’s neck without fitting. In other words, there are so many variables involved in the shape and size of a horse’s neck that the only accurate and easy way to size the neck is to use several collars and put them on one at a time until fitting is found.

The Milk and Human Kindness A Look At Butter Churns

The Milk and Human Kindness: A Look at Butter Churns

by:
from issue:

Finding an old butter churn at a flea market, one that is still usable can be a lot of fun, and because there are so many types, it’s good to know a few tips to help you find one that works well for you. For one thing, the size of your butter churn must match your cream supply so that your valuable cream gets transformed into golden butter while it’s fresh and sweet, and that your valuable time is not eaten up by churning batch after batch because your churn is too small.

The Tip Cart

The Tip Cart

by:
from issue:

When horses were the main source of power on every farm, in the British Isles it was the tip-cart, rather than the wagon which was the most common vehicle, and for anyone farming with horses, it is still an extremely useful and versatile piece of equipment. The farm cart was used all over the country, indeed in some places wagons were scarcely used at all, and many small farms in other areas only used carts.

Living With Horses

Living With Horses

by:
from issue:

The French breed of Ardennes is closer to what the breed has been in the past. The Ardennes has always been a stockier type of horse, rude as its environment. Today the breed has dramatically changed into a real heavy horse. If the Ardennes had an average weight between 550 and 700kg in the first part of the last century, the balance shows today 1000kg and more. Thus the difference between the Ardennes and their “big” sisters, the Brabants in Belgium, or the Trait du Nord in France, has gone.

Ask A Teamster Tongue Length

Ask A Teamster: Tongue Length

My forecart pole is set up for draft horses. My husband thinks we should cut the pole off to permanently make it fit better to these smaller horses. What would be your opinion? Like your husband, my preference would be a shorter tongue for a small team like your Fjords. The dynamics and efficiency of draft are better if we have our horse(s) close to the load. A shorter tongue will also reduce the overall length of your outfit, thereby giving you better maneuverability and turning dynamics.

Step Ahead Horse Progress Days 2016

Step Ahead: 23rd Annual Horse Progress Days 2016

by:
from issue:

I had only been to Horse Progress Days once before, at Mount Hope, Ohio in 2008. It had been an eye-opener, showing how strong and in touch with sustainable farming values the Amish are, and how innovative and sensible their efforts could be. So at the 23rd annual event in Howe, Indiana, I was there partly looking for signs of continuity, and partly for signs of change. Right off I spotted an Amish man with a Blue Tooth in his ear, talking as he walked along.

The New Idea No5 Transplanter

The NEW IDEA No. 5 Transplanter

from issue:

The planting distances or intervals at which the water is released, is controlled by the gear and pinions under the shield near the driver’s right foot. The large, flat-faced gear should be so turned that the arrow on the back points straight up. The numbers on either side of the arrow will then be so arranged that the number 1, 2, 3 and 4 will be on the side of the water trip lever and will denote the various positions in which the Driven Pinion meshes with the gear.

Cole One Horse Planters

Cole One Horse Planters

by:
from issue:

The most populous single horse planting tools were made by Planet Junior. But they were by no means the only company producing these small farm gems. Most manufacturers included a few models and some, like Planet Junior, American and Cole specialized in the implement. What follows are fourteen different models from Cole’s, circa 1910, catalog. We published ten of these in volume 30 number three of Small Farmer’s Journal.

Hay Making with a Single Horse Part 2

Hay Making with a Single Horse Part 2

by:
from issue:

From reading the Small Farmers Journal, I knew that some people are equally happy with either model, but because McCormick Deering had gone to the trouble of developing the No. 9, it suggests they could see that there were improvements to be made on the No. 7. Even if the improvement was small, with a single horse any improvement was likely to increase my chance of success.

Haying With Horses

Haying With Horses

If the reader is considering the construction of a barn we encourage you to give more than passing thought to allowing the structure of the gable to be open enough to accommodate the hanging of a trolley track. It is difficult or impossible to retrofit a truss-built barn, which may have many supports crisscrossing the inside gable, to receive hay jags. At least allowing for the option in a new construction design will leave the option for loose hay systems in the future.

New Horse-drawn Side Delivery Rakes from Europe

New Horse-drawn Side Delivery Rakes from Europe

In Northern Italy the two agricultural machinery manufacturers MAINARDI A. s.r.l. and REPOSSI Macchine Agricole s.r.l. produce a vast range of haying equipment with pto and hydraulic drive, also hay rakes with mechanical drive by the rear wheels. The majority of the sold machines of this type are currently used with small tractors and motor cultivators. The technology of these rakes is based on implements which were developed in the 1940s, when animal traction still played an important role in Italy’s agriculture.

A Pony-Powered Garden Cart

A Pony-Powered Garden Cart

by:
from issue:

One of the challenges I constantly face using draft ponies is finding appropriately sized equipment. Mya is a Shetland-Welsh cross, standing at 11.2 hands. Most manure spreaders are big and heavy and require a team of horses. I needed something small and light and preferably wheeled to minimize impact to the land. My husband and I looked around our budding small farm for something light, wheeled, cheap, and available, and we quickly noticed our Vermont-style garden cart.

Farm Drum 28 Eds Wester Star Custom Forecart

Farm Drum #28: Ed’s Western Star Custom Forecart

Lynn Miller and Ed Joseph examine a custom horse-drawn Forecart built by Ed’s company, Western Star Implement Co.

Farm Drum 27 Case 22 x 36 Threshing Machine

Farm Drum #27: Case 22 x 36 Threshing Machine

by:

Friend and Auctioneer Dennis Turmon has an upcoming auction featuring a Case Threshing machine, and we couldn’t wait when he invited us to take a look. On a blustery Central Oregon day (sorry about the wind noise), Lynn & Dennis take us on a guided tour of the Case 22×36 Thresher.

Homemade Ground-Drive PTO Forecart

Homemade Ground-Drive PTO Forecart

by:
from issue:

As we start, consider a few things when building a pto cart. Are big drive tires necessary? Is a lot of weight needed? Imagine the cart in use. Try to see it working where you normally go and where you almost never go. Will it be safe and easy to mount or dismount? Can you access the controls of the implement conveniently? Is it easy to hook and unhook? Where is the balance point? I’m sure you will think of other details as you daydream about it.

Delivery Wagon Plans

Delivery Wagon Plans

from issue:

While the low down delivery wagon is an improvement, the objectionable features are increased. But with all those objections the low down wagons increase every year. Their convenience outweighs all other objections. They are handy for country delivery and are fitted up inside to suit either grocers, bakers, butchers or milk delivery, or a combination of the four.

Small Farmer's Journal

Small Farmer's Journal
PO Box 1627
Sisters, Oregon 97759
800-876-2893
541-549-2064
agrarian@smallfarmersjournal.com
Mon - Thu, 8am - 4pm PDT